Out of Cashew Butter? Try These Delicious Substitutes in Your Recipes!

One of those butter varieties that melts on your tongue and brightens your day is cashew butter. It’s a great option for spreading on bread, and its flavor is distinctive. However, cashew butter is not flawless either. If it doesn’t match your lifestyle or you are allergic to it, you can always find a substitute.

Given that it has a nutty flavor that is comparable to cashew butter and a strong nutritious profile, peanut butter is the ideal alternative. Peanut butter is unquestionably what you require if you’re seeking a pleasant and healthful food. Other wonderful alternatives are also Soy nut butter, Sunflower butter, Almont butter, Walnut butter, pecan Butter, Hazelnut Butter, and Homemade cashew butter.

What Is Cashew Butter

The name of this nut butter, created from cashews, pretty much says it all. The majority of the time, cashews are processed into a smooth, creamy spreadable consistency in a blender or food processor. To make the butter more appetizing, some producers could additionally add a few more additives.

The flavor of cashew butter is essentially identical to that of raw cashews. You may simply use and enjoy it since it has a straightforward, solid texture that is nutty and creamy. Because it’s so simple to create, cashew butter is also a favorite of many people. Therefore, you might just create it if there aren’t any brand choices close by.

Cashew butter may be used on toast, much as other butter spreads. Although this is mostly for those who would desire to experiment with their recipes, some individuals also use it to make ice cream. It is a great substitute for peanut butter in sandwiches and may also be used as a dipping sauce or in baking.

In addition, magnesium, phosphorus, and zinc are among the essential elements found in cashew butter. These nutrients are necessary for healthy bone metabolism and growth. Whatever method you use to consume it, cashew butter is a delectable and healthy option.

Best Substitutes for Cashew Butter

Substitute:	Best For
Peanut Butter	Cookies, Baked goods, Sandwiches, Toast,  Smoothies, Breakfast cereal, Oatmeal
Soy Nut Butter	Sandwiches, Pancakes
Sunflower Butter	Brownies, Oatmeal, Toast
Almond Butter	Toast, Smoothies, Keto bread, Breakfast cereal
Walnut Butter	Baked goods, breakfast cereal
Pecan Butter	Brownies, Pancakes, Oatmeal, Keto bread, Smoothies
Hazelnut Butter	Cookies, Breakfast cereal
Homemade Cashew Butter	Cookies, Baked goods, Smoothies, Toast, Sandwiches, Oatmeal

People who are allergic to nuts will very certainly also be allergic to cashew butter. This is a real problem, especially given the prevalence of nut allergies. Therefore, if you fit this description, you would need to find a stand-in. Cashew butter has a delicious flavor, but it is not widely accessible. A replacement will be much better for you if you struggle to have it done around you. So, let’s explore the best substitutes for cashew butter.

1. Peanut Butter

Peanut butter is essentially the most adaptable of the several types of butter. It functions with almost everything and can serve as a dependable replacement for any other variation. Therefore, it should come as no surprise that peanut butter is everyone’s preferred spread.

As you may anticipate, cashew butter and peanut butter have different tastes. Both won’t taste the same because they are prepared from different ingredients. However, peanut butter has a subtle taste undertone that somewhat resembles cashew butter. The resemblance is therefore highly intriguing.

Peanut butter works in almost anything that works for cashew butter due to its distinct nutty taste. The two are similar in terms of nutrition as well; similar to cashew butter, peanut butter is a good source of vitamins including vitamin E and vitamin B. Additionally, peanut butter has more proteins than cashew butter, which is another advantage.

Finally, compared to cashew butter, peanut butter is far more widely accessible. It’s accessible, reasonably priced, and prepared for you. The only drawback of peanut butter is that it can easily make people allergic to it. You should absolutely avoid this one if you are lactose intolerant or allergic to peanuts.

2. Soy Nut Butter

Soy nut butter is an intriguing alternative that might easily replace cashew butter but is seldom known. This butter is created from roasted soybeans, as the name would imply, along with additional salt and oil. Some companies could additionally enhance the flavor of their meals by using ingredients like sugar and palm oil.

You obtain a rich and creamy structure with soy nut butter. However, some people might find the bland flavor of the buttery flavor to be quite off-putting. Once more, this explains why certain products include sugar. To give your dish even more flavor, you could also include some jam.

Soy nut butter is quite outstanding nutritionally. In a tablespoon portion, you receive enough calories, healthy fats, and just a little bit more than one gram of unsaturated fat. A few grams of protein are also provided by soy nut butter, and the spread contains sizable levels of minerals including calcium and iron.

Soy nut butter is unlikely to cause any nut allergies because it is manufactured from soybeans. Due to its rather bland flavor character, it may be used in a variety of dishes. Soy nut butter may be used for the same things as cashew butter can be.

3. Sunflower Butter

Sunflower butter is the ideal alternative if you’re trying to replicate the flavor of cashew butter. This alternative usually referred to as sunflower seed butter is suitable for those who are allergic to nuts.

Made from crushed and roasted sunflower seeds, sunflower butter has a nutty flavor that strikes the ideal balance between dominance and mildness. The flavor is powerful enough to draw your attention, but not so much so that you stop noticing other flavors.

Sunflower butter adds flavor to every dish because of its unique flavor. It is also quite simple to locate and won’t change the flavor of your dish.

4. Almond Butter

A tasty and healthy substitute for cashew butter is almond butter. Both cashew butter and almond butter have a creamy texture that makes them perfect for spreading over toast or mixing into smoothies, however, cashew butter is often sweeter than almond butter.

While cashew butter is lower in fat and calories, almond butter is also a rich source of protein, fiber, and healthy fats. Almond butter also has a higher vitamin and mineral content than cashew butter. Almond butter may be used as a tasty and wholesome replacement in any dish and is generally a better choice than cashew butter.

5. Walnut Butter

Cashew butter can be used in place of walnut butter if you have a cashew allergy or just prefer the flavor of walnuts. Although the flavor and feel of the two types of butter are comparable, there are some important distinctions to remember when switching.

First, you might want to reduce the amount of sugar in your recipe as walnuts are a little sweeter than cashews. Second, because walnut butter is thinner than cashew butter, you might need to modify the temperature or baking time.

6. Pecan Butter

Pecans are a terrific alternative to cashew butter and have amazing health advantages. Nut pecans are good for the heart. They include more than 19 different vitamins and minerals, including folic acid, potassium, phosphorus, and vitamins A, B, and E, and they reduce your cholesterol levels.

Pecans are a great source of antioxidants and can even aid with weight management. The greatest thing is that they contain no sodium, so anyone who must manage their salt or sodium consumption may enjoy a snack of pecan butter without concern.

7. Hazelnut Butter

Hazelnut Butter could be the most delicious substitute for cashew butter.  Not only is it tasty, but hazelnuts, which are high in vitamins and nutritional fiber, make it healthful as well. They also assist in reducing harmful cholesterol.

Don’t overdo it, even though this butter may be a healthy complement to your diet. Some of the most popular varieties have several ingredients, such as sugar and chocolate.

Homemade Cashew Butter

Although butter in jars from the store is fantastic, you can also create your own. The process of making peanut butter is very simple and it can be done in several simple steps.

Process cashews that have been salted and roasted in the food processor. It will begin to clump and adhere to the sides soon. Start the food processor again after stopping it to clean the sides.

Pour the melted coconut oil into the cashew butter as it is grinding. Wait for it until it has the consistency of cashew butter, which is smooth and creamy. Cashew butter can be made in a blender, but they get much trickier in texture.

Bottom Line

Do you wish to avoid cashews for health reasons or because you have an allergy to them? It’s not just you. Many people have allergies or sensitivities that prevent them from appreciating the nutty flavor of cashews. Or maybe you are in the middle of cooking and just found out that you are out of cashew butter.

Above in this article, we explored several best substitutes for cashew butter. Fortunately, there are a number of alternatives to cashew butter that may have the same luxurious texture and mouthwatering flavor.