Best Spike Seasoning Substitutes

Top 6 Best Spike Seasoning Substitutes: Flavorful & Healthy Alternatives

Spike seasoning is so popular because of its fantastic blend of 39 nutritious ingredients. Still, some might not be able to afford it, others might find it too much. Whatever this is, you’ll get a good taste instantly with this seasoning. If you can’t use spike seasoning, no worries. They have some of the best spike seasoning substitutes available in the market.

Some of the best-spoken seasoning substitutes are: McCormick, Chef Paul Prudhomme’s magic seasoning, Tony Chachere’s Original Creole Seasoning, Mrs Dash, Herbes de Provence and Old Bay seasoning. Eac of them are specialised in making different dishes. 

What To Look For In A Substitute For Spike Seasoning?

Spike seasoning is meant to be a quick fix to your dish. So, if you’re searching for a good substitute for it, make sure the taste is similar. Well, it is not necessary that the ingredients have to be similar. 

However, ensure they are blended well and do not overpower the real taste of your dish. Another thing while searching for a good spike seasoning substitute is time. Spike seasoning is meanest to do its job really quickly without any reaction. 

Also, the seasoning must be nutritious. You can do various kinds of magic by using some unhealthy elements in your food, But that should not be the purpose at all. 

So, whichever substitute you choose for spike seasoning must be nutritious and delicious. 

6 Best Spike Seasoning Substitutes

Reminding all the things you need to consider, here are the six best spike seasoning substitutes available. All of these are quite affordable and competitive in the market. 

You better go through the details before jumping on to any:

1. McCormick blends

McCormick blends are an all-purpose seasoning that adds incredible taste to your food. It is made instant using technology. This doesn’t require separate mixing or no extra spices. McCormick blends also have varieties of different recipes. 

This blend is popular, especially in Mexican and Italian cuisine. People prefer it in dishes based on chicken, seafood, and vegetables. Here you’ll get various nutritious elements like garlic, oregano, herbs, sea salt, lemon peel and peppers.

This brand understands you might only gather some of the ingredients specifically in all regions. So, it has brought the necessary spices in a well-blended formula for better taste in your food.

2. Chef Paul Prudhomme’s Magic Seasoning

Chef Paul Prudhomme’s magic seasoning is recommended for use in roasted, grilled, baked, barbecued or fried dishes. They can save you from the hassle of using other species separately in the right amount. 

It will include everything from salt, herbs, peppers and spices. The best thing is this is made of all-natural ingredients. 

Here you’ll get chillies, different types of onion, roasted garlic, different kinds of peppers, brown sugar, paprika, vinegar and other incredible spices. So, you’re certainly getting nutrition blended in a package here. 

Another amazing thing about this seasoning is you can use this on almost everything. It will bring the perfect flavor out without any extra work done. Besides, its versatility and using procedure are other things that make it a better substitute for spike seasoning.

3. Tony Chachere’s Original Creole Seasoning

Tony Chachere’s Original Creole Seasoning includes a very small amount of seasonings. Still, the taste will be mouthwatering when you use this seasoning in your food. It has varieties of use with a very light yet tasty flavor. 

However, producers need to mention the secret of these incredible blends on the package. Yet, it is popularly used worldwide for marinating, dressing and special mixing. Although these have versatile use, you can try them specifically with vegetables. 

This seasoning gives an amazing blend to vegetables that other seasonings can’t. It can be found online and offline both easily. So, you can give it a shot anytime. 

4. Mrs Dash Seasoning

Do you want to avoid salt and yet want your food to be tasty? Well, that is when you’ll blindly trust Mrs Dash’s seasoning. 

From burgers and mac and cheese to regular veggies, everything gets mouth watering with this Dash seasoning. It is also free from MSG. So, it can be considered best for health-conscious people. Besides, the taste of this seasoning is a bit earthy and less spicy. 

After mixing it in your food, you’ll get a soothing aromatic smell because of the herbs. Well, it can bring a bold flavor to your food. So, this is for people who want a more robust flavor than spike seasoning.

5. Herbes de Provence

Herbes de Provence is a special seasoning that originated in France. So, you might have assumed already that this seasoning is produced specially for french food. However, it does magic for other cuisines as well. 


t is known to be an all-purpose seasoning. It includes thyme, basil, rosemary, oregano, bay leaf, savory, marjoram and tarragon. This seasoning gets blended equally in meat, fish, liquids or grilled items. Well, it will bring a subtle aromatic flavor to any dish.

However, don’t use too much of it as this can make the food bitter. But to bring a better taste to it, you need to use salt and garlic powder in similar amounts.

6. Old Bay Seasoning

Old bay seasoning is made with 18 different herbs to make any food more delicious. It can be used on fish, chicken, soup and vegetables. This company also seems to keep their entire ingredient list secret. 

Although salt, paprika, celery seed, red and black pepper are their basic ingredients. Here you’ll get a strong and zesty flavor. As it includes mustard, it will also give a tint of sweetness to your dish. 

This seasoning is especially recommended for the seafood lover. If you check the top-rated seafood recipes,most of them seem to use old bay seasoning. 

Special Addition: Homemade Spike Seasoning Mix

Well, if you don’t want to risk choosing the wrong one, you can try making seasoning at home. This will require less of your energy and bucks if you know the correct process. 

Step 1: Let’s start with gathering these ingredients:

  • 1 tsp dried basil
  • 2 tsp onion powder
  • 1 tsp dry mustard
  • 1 tbsp sweet paprika
  • 2 ¾ tsp black pepper
  • 1 tsp cayenne
  • 2 tbsp kosher salt
  • 1 ½ tsp dried thyme leaves
  • 1 ¼ tsp garlic powder

Step 2: Give them a good mix:

Get a clean spice/ coffee grinder. Both of them will help you here. Now, mix them all together and blend well until they turn into a smooth and powdery form. 

Step 3: Store it well:

Now, take a clean glass jar with a tight lid. Here checking the lid is essential, or else the seasoning aroma will disappear soon. Take a clean funnel and carefully get the blended seasoning into the jar. Close the lid well and keep it somewhere cool and dry.

Now, it’s ready to use for months. And you can, of course, add the ingredients regarding your needs.  

Tips For Using Substitutes Effectively

Well, there are a few things to remember while using spike seasoning substitutes, you need to remember. These will keep your cooking game up and your health risk down. 

Check here:

  • Don’t use too much seasoning to taste similar to spike seasoning. This will just ruin the authentic taste of your dish.
  • Don’t just pick any random seating. Understand what your recipe requires. Some seasonings are good for seafood, others do better with meat-based dishes. So, consider what your need is.
  • Well, not all seasoning will include an ingredient list. If you have got an allergic reaction to any specific ingredient that could be used in the seasoning, talk with the company first.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best seasoning for steak?

Any seasoning that is based on salt and pepper will be best for steak. Salt and pepper make your food juicy. And steaks will need a lot of salt, pepper and other spices to bring the ultimate taste with every bite.

Can you make your own spike seasoning?

Yes, you can make your spike seasoning at home any time. It will only require the basic ingredients mentioned on the spike seasoning packaging. If you can gather these all and give them a good blend, they will be ready to use. 

Wrap Up

It is a bit difficult to describe the taste of seasoning without using it. They are meant to give your dish a unique favor. So, you will not find all of them in similar taste. If you really like the taste of spike seasoning but can’t find it, try other substitutes mentioned here. All of them are incredible in their own way. However, if nothing works for you, just go for the homemade seasoning recipe.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *